icon-location Sanibel & Captiva Island, FL
icon-knife-fork

Find the Best Restaurants in Sanibel & Captiva Island
Search Hundreds of Menus, Photos, and Reviews

icon-search

Looking to explore more than just dining? Visit our all-new Best of Sanibel & Captiva Island page where you will find Things to Do, Attractions, Shopping, Nite Life, and so much more.

  • icon-nitelifeNite Life
  • icon-shoppingShopping
  • icon-attractionsAttractions
icon-chevron-rightVisit Best of Sanibel & Captiva Island

icon-megaphoneNew Restaurants in Sanibel & Captiva Island

Blue Giraffe

icon-green-checkmarkDine In
icon-green-checkmarkTakeout
icon-red-XDelivery
American$$
We are Open!
Blue Giraffe on southwest Florida’s Sanibel Island is located in the Periwinkle Place Shopping Center. If you’re looking to kick back and take it easy with a tropical beverage, or an ice cold local IPA AND you’re hungry, join the locals and dine inside where a full liquor bar awaits or outside on the pet friendly patio. The menu at Blue Giraffe is diverse and features breakfast, seafood, custom burgers, Mexican, wraps, salads and sandwiches. Try our Signature Cuban or Grouper Sandwich for lunch or dinner. We even have a kids menu at Blue Giraffe so there is something for everyone in your family to enjoy.
icon-locationSanibel Island

Cheeburger Cheeburger

icon-green-checkmarkDine In
icon-green-checkmarkTakeout
icon-green-checkmarkDelivery
American, Burgers$
Opened since 1986, Cheeburger Cheeburger is a 1950s style burger restaurant that specializes in cheeseburgers, freshly cut french fries, onion rings, milkshakes and more! With outdoor dining and the best burgers you've ever had Cheeburger Cheeburger is open for lunch and dinner daily.
icon-locationSanibel Island

Crow's Nest Steakhouse

icon-green-checkmarkDine In
icon-green-checkmarkTakeout
icon-red-XDelivery
American, Local Fare, Seafood, Steak House, Steakhouse$$$
Dining That’s Truly Over The Top. Welcome to Crow’s Nest Steakhouse where, deliciously and beautifully, you can expand your horizons. Crow’s Nest Steakhouse stands tall above the acclaimed Shipyard Restaurant at ‘Tween Waters Island Resort & Spa of Captiva. Crow’s Nest Steakhouse is the only second-level dining destination on Captiva or Sanibel with a glorious beachfront view of the Gulf of Mexico and its amazing sunsets.
icon-locationCaptiva Island

Sweet Melissa's

icon-green-checkmarkDine In
icon-green-checkmarkTakeout
icon-red-XDelivery
American, Contemporary American$$
Sweet Melissa's Cafe is a culinary gem in Fort Myers, offering a vibrant dining experience that delights the senses. Led by Chef Melissa Donahue, the menu features fresh, seasonal ingredients, showcasing innovative seafood dishes and perfectly cooked steaks that highlight her culinary talent. The inviting ambiance, with elegant decor and a cozy patio, creates the perfect backdrop for any occasion, whether it's a celebration or a casual night out with friends. The attentive staff is dedicated to ensuring your dining experience is exceptional, while the extensive wine list pairs beautifully with your meal. Don't miss out on dessert! Chef Melissa's signature treats, like the rich chocolate lava cake, are the perfect way to end your meal. Visit Sweet Melissa's Cafe for an unforgettable culinary journey that will leave you craving more.
icon-locationFort Myers

icon-thumbs-upClassic Establishments in Sanibel & Captiva Island

Blue Giraffe

icon-green-checkmarkDine In
icon-green-checkmarkTakeout
icon-red-XDelivery
American$$
We are Open!
Blue Giraffe on southwest Florida’s Sanibel Island is located in the Periwinkle Place Shopping Center. If you’re looking to kick back and take it easy with a tropical beverage, or an ice cold local IPA AND you’re hungry, join the locals and dine inside where a full liquor bar awaits or outside on the pet friendly patio. The menu at Blue Giraffe is diverse and features breakfast, seafood, custom burgers, Mexican, wraps, salads and sandwiches. Try our Signature Cuban or Grouper Sandwich for lunch or dinner. We even have a kids menu at Blue Giraffe so there is something for everyone in your family to enjoy.
icon-locationSanibel Island

Cantina Captiva

icon-green-checkmarkDine In
icon-green-checkmarkTakeout
icon-red-XDelivery
Mexican, Southwestern$
Island prices burning a hole in your pocket? Come to Cantina Captiva for the best Mexican food and Margaritas on the island! Enjoy unique and spicy atmosphere while savoring the fine Mexican and Southwestern cuisine. To complement the evening choose from an array of imported and domestic beers and wines, not to mention refreshing margaritas.
icon-locationCaptiva Island

Captiva Island Pizza

icon-green-checkmarkDine In
icon-green-checkmarkTakeout
icon-green-checkmarkDelivery
Pizza$$
We are open!
Welcome to Captiva Island Pizza, located in the Captiva Village! Call ahead or come on by to order your own custom pizza ready for you to take back to your hotel or condo or down to the beach for sunset!
icon-locationCaptiva Island

Cheeburger Cheeburger

icon-green-checkmarkDine In
icon-green-checkmarkTakeout
icon-green-checkmarkDelivery
American, Burgers$
Opened since 1986, Cheeburger Cheeburger is a 1950s style burger restaurant that specializes in cheeseburgers, freshly cut french fries, onion rings, milkshakes and more! With outdoor dining and the best burgers you've ever had Cheeburger Cheeburger is open for lunch and dinner daily.
icon-locationSanibel Island

Cielo

icon-green-checkmarkDine In
icon-green-checkmarkTakeout
icon-red-XDelivery
Farm to Table, International$$$
When it comes to Sanibel dining, Cielo is setting a new bar in farm to table cuisine. We strive for the best in everything we do, from carefully crafted cocktails to creative dishes made from scratch. In a world where the word “fresh” is ubiquitous, we take things further, locally sourcing only the best ingredients and hand-crafting every dish with the utmost care.
icon-locationSanibel Island

Crow's Nest Steakhouse

icon-green-checkmarkDine In
icon-green-checkmarkTakeout
icon-red-XDelivery
American, Local Fare, Seafood, Steak House, Steakhouse$$$
Dining That’s Truly Over The Top. Welcome to Crow’s Nest Steakhouse where, deliciously and beautifully, you can expand your horizons. Crow’s Nest Steakhouse stands tall above the acclaimed Shipyard Restaurant at ‘Tween Waters Island Resort & Spa of Captiva. Crow’s Nest Steakhouse is the only second-level dining destination on Captiva or Sanibel with a glorious beachfront view of the Gulf of Mexico and its amazing sunsets.
icon-locationCaptiva Island

Island Pizza Company

icon-green-checkmarkDine In
icon-green-checkmarkTakeout
icon-green-checkmarkDelivery
Italian, Pizza$
Experience the charm of Italian cuisine in a laid-back setting, featuring a diverse menu that includes a variety of pizzas, pastas, and subs. Complement your meal with traditional burgers, draft beers, or choose from a curated selection of wines. Whether you’re in the mood for a casual dinner or a leisurely lunch, this dining spot promises a delightful array of options to satisfy your cravings.
icon-locationSanibel Island

Jerry’s Café

icon-green-checkmarkDine In
icon-green-checkmarkTakeout
icon-red-XDelivery
American, Classic, Local Fare, Seafood$
We are open! Keep an eye on our Facebook page for updates on hours.
Jerry’s Café is open seven days a week for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Enjoy fresh-made breakfast pastries, signature sandwiches (check out our grouper!), delicious dinner entrees, and fabulous desserts – like our fan-favorite Key Lime Pie – all while enjoying our tropical bird habitat. In addition to our full menu we offer a build-your-own gourmet salad and sandwich bar, exciting daily specials, a fantastic full menu, and a wide assortment of beer and wine.
icon-locationSanibel Island

Keylime Bistro - Captiva

icon-green-checkmarkDine In
icon-green-checkmarkTakeout
icon-red-XDelivery
American, Seafood$
Now Open!
The Award winning Keylime Bistro serving breakfast, lunch and dinner is sure to tantalize the most demanding palate, with a full bar and live entertainment featured 7 days and nights. Awarded News Press 1st Place Island Dining.
icon-locationCaptiva Island

Lighthouse Waterfront Restaurant

icon-green-checkmarkDine In
icon-green-checkmarkTakeout
icon-red-XDelivery
American, Mediterranean$$$
The Lighthouse Waterfront Restaurant overlooks the entrance to the exclusive Connie Mack Island. Inside, you’ll enjoy a relaxed atmosphere, the choice of fine or casual dining with a full liquor bar, comfortable lounge and the area’s best live entertainment. Our outside seating features a dockside view where exotic wildlife live in peaceful harmony with million dollar yachts. The expansive 160’ outdoor porch is especially popular for spectacular sunsets. For your comfort, outdoor dining is under cover, screened and heated on that rare chilly evening.
icon-locationFort Myers

Magic Bus on Sanibel

icon-green-checkmarkDine In
icon-red-XTakeout
icon-red-XDelivery
Bakery, Coffee Bar, Desserts, Ice Cream, Pastries, Smoothies, Speciality & Gift Shops$
At the Magic Bus you will get to fulfill all your sweet tooth desires. We have 26 delicious flavors of premium ice cream to choose from. Indulge in our specialty milkshakes and ice cream sundaes! Treat yourself to our fresh brewed lattes, frappes, and iced coffees. We have a large selection of fun candies from chocolates and caramels to gummies and taffy. Pick up some fresh made pastries or a refreshing fruit smoothie! We have something sweet to satisfy everyone!
icon-locationSanibel Island

MudBugs Cajun Kitchen

icon-green-checkmarkDine In
icon-green-checkmarkTakeout
icon-green-checkmarkDelivery
Cajun Creole, Fresh Seafood, Oysters$$
We are open!
Bourbon Street at the Beach! New Orleans classics, with a Sanibel twist. Serving traditional island fare with a Cajun twist, MudBugs Cajun Kitchen is open for lunch and dinner. With two full bars located upstairs and downstairs, live music, a fun, laid back atmosphere...oh and did we mention Crawfish and Grilled Oysters? MudBugs Cajun Kitchen is sure to become your favorite island spots.
icon-locationSanibel Island

Old Captiva House

icon-green-checkmarkDine In
icon-green-checkmarkTakeout
icon-red-XDelivery
American, Seafood, Steaks$$, $$$
Open for Breakfast, Lunch, and Dinner!
Delight in the delectable at the Old Captiva House restaurant, located at the legendary ‘Tween Waters Island Resort. & Spa — the only fine dining and sushi restaurant on Captiva Island with a Gulf-front view of America’s Most Romantic Sunset. This charming and historic restaurant boasts a menu of mouth-watering island favorites and local seafood, plus other delights including fresh breads, desserts, and an extensive wine collection. Dine casual or formal at this 100+-year-old former school house, newly renovated to reflect quality and service with an ode to the tradition of this historic marker.
icon-locationCaptiva Island

Phuzzy’s Boat Shack

icon-green-checkmarkDine In
icon-green-checkmarkTakeout
icon-red-XDelivery
American, Seafood$$
Old-school joint on a canal with a funky outdoor bar for rum drinks & beer, plus burgers & seafood.
icon-locationPine Island

Pinocchio’s Original Italian Ice Cream

icon-green-checkmarkDine In
icon-green-checkmarkTakeout
icon-red-XDelivery
American, Desserts, Frozen Confections, Gelato, Ice Cream, Italian, Pastry, Specialty Coffees$
WE ARE BACK! This is a long time for all of us to recuperate, rebuild and reconnect but we are so very happy to announce the reopening of Pinocchio's on Sanibel Island. We have a lot to be thankful for. Our Customers who called, texted and emailed to check on us, our general contractor Jamie Swagler and Forthwright Construction who made us whole again, the vendors and the utility companies who restored services and product offerings and especially our landlord and staff at Periwinkle Place Shops who were there with us every step of the way. We are so very excited for you to return to Pinocchio's, a Sanibel tradition for 44 years and we look forward to many memorable years ahead. A Sanibel tradition since 1980, now loyal fans say Pinocchio’s is their first stop on the island before checking into their accommodations and the last place they frequent before they head home. Fans know Pinocchio’s is not just about ice cream. It’s a dessert experience. All of Pinocchio’s award wining frozen confections are handcrafted daily in their little green shops from the finest and freshest ingredients. Creating unique, memorable flavors such as Sanibel Krunch©, Dirty Sand Dollar©, Wedding Bells©, Gator Stew© and signature Key Lime Frozen Yogurt are the creative core of the Pinocchio’s brand. Daily dessert offerings include at least 36 flavors from their repertoire of over 200+ recipes of Ice Cream, Gelato, Sorbet and Sorbetto, Frozen Yogurt, Italian Custard and even Semi Freddo. Unique flavors, generous portions, a signature animal cracker on top of each product and friendly service all served in their new locations: The only Pinocchio’s on Sanibel at Periwinkle Place Shops and in Ft Myers at the Village Shops at Health Park. Come See Why There’s Always A Crowd at Pinocchio’s. It’s Simply the Best!...We Cannot Tell A Lie!
icon-locationSanibel Island

RC Otter’s Island Eats - Captiva

icon-green-checkmarkDine In
icon-green-checkmarkTakeout
icon-red-XDelivery
American, Seafood$
Award-winning RC Otter’s Island Eats is a place for the whole family! Located in the Heart of Old Captiva Village with lovely shopping and dining, you can enjoy live music daily with dining inside and outside. Open daily.
icon-locationCaptiva Island

Sanibel Deli and Coffee Factory

icon-green-checkmarkDine In
icon-green-checkmarkTakeout
icon-red-XDelivery
American, Coffee House, Delicatessen$
We are open!
The Sanibel Deli is known to be a favorite local hangout and spot for the best coffee, breakfast, lunch and dinner on Sanibel Island. Winner of the Best Pizza at Taste of the Islands, Sanibel Deli offers wi-fi, indoor and outdoor seating, and an extensive line of gluten free options, The Sanibel Deli is the only place to go for delicious food at unbeatable prices!
icon-locationSanibel Island

Sunshine Seafood Cafe - Captiva

icon-green-checkmarkDine In
icon-red-XTakeout
icon-red-XDelivery
Continental, Local Fare, Seafood$$
Sunshine Seafood Café & Wine Bar is located on beautiful Captiva Island, just minutes from the Gulf of Mexico. We grill up fresh seafood, steaks and lamb chops on our wood grill. The atmosphere is tropical, with a strong emphasis on knowledgeable, attentive service and outstanding seafood cuisine.
icon-locationCaptiva Island

Sweet Melissa's

icon-green-checkmarkDine In
icon-green-checkmarkTakeout
icon-red-XDelivery
American, Contemporary American$$
Sweet Melissa's Cafe is a culinary gem in Fort Myers, offering a vibrant dining experience that delights the senses. Led by Chef Melissa Donahue, the menu features fresh, seasonal ingredients, showcasing innovative seafood dishes and perfectly cooked steaks that highlight her culinary talent. The inviting ambiance, with elegant decor and a cozy patio, creates the perfect backdrop for any occasion, whether it's a celebration or a casual night out with friends. The attentive staff is dedicated to ensuring your dining experience is exceptional, while the extensive wine list pairs beautifully with your meal. Don't miss out on dessert! Chef Melissa's signature treats, like the rich chocolate lava cake, are the perfect way to end your meal. Visit Sweet Melissa's Cafe for an unforgettable culinary journey that will leave you craving more.
icon-locationFort Myers

The Great White Grill

icon-green-checkmarkDine In
icon-green-checkmarkTakeout
icon-green-checkmarkDelivery
American, Pizza, Sports Bar$
We are open! Check our Facebook page for updates on hours.
The Great White Grill has been voted the best Lunch, best beer selection and best place to watch the game on Sanibel and Captiva. We take pride in offering delicious eats and great times at the Great White Grill. Delivery available to anywhere on the island. We have a variety of items to fit every taste bud, including the best pizza, wings, sandwiches, and gyros in town. We also have a wide selection of 19 beers on tap, including local craft selections.
icon-locationSanibel Island

The Mucky Duck Neighborhood Pub

icon-red-XDine In
icon-red-XTakeout
icon-red-XDelivery
American, Pub Fare$$
Temporarily Closed
Located deep in the heart of downtown Captiva, where the sun sets nightly. At The Mucky Duck Neighborhood Pub, the beer is always cold, our menu specializes in the best delicacies and fresh seafood, and the sunsets are always breathtaking!
icon-locationCaptiva Island

Tutti Pazzi Italian Kitchen

icon-green-checkmarkDine In
icon-green-checkmarkTakeout
icon-red-XDelivery
Italian, Pizza, Seafood$$, $$$
Welcome to Tutti Pazzi Italian Kitchen — where you enter as a guest, become our friend, and feel like family. In Italy, the dinner table is where magic happens. Friends and family gather to fill their bodies with good food and wine; and their souls with laughter, happiness, and love.
icon-locationSanibel Island

Wickies Lighthouse Restaurant

icon-green-checkmarkDine In
icon-green-checkmarkTakeout
icon-red-XDelivery
American, Contemporary, Seafood$$, $$$
Join us for a delicious meal for breakfast, lunch, or dinner at Wickies Lighthouse Restaurant! (Next door to Magic Bus) We serve upscale meals in a casual atmosphere. Grab a seat at our full liquor bar as we serve up specialty craft beverages. Feel free to stop by our walk-up window to grab a drink and quick bite while you dine at any of our outdoor bars or tables. Dogs are welcome to our outdoor dining area.
icon-locationSanibel Island